Last Friday, The Washington Post reported that Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth gave a spoken order to lethally attack a boat off the coast of Trinidad. “The order was to kill everybody,” a source told the Post. To comply with Hegseth’s order, the Navy special operations commander overseeing the September 2 attack ordered a second strike on the boat, after an initial hit left two survivors, and 11 people were killed in total. Following the revelations, leaders of the bipartisan House and Senate armed services committees issued statements promising inquiries into the report.
Legal experts have argued that the killings could constitute a war crime. Even Newsmax’s senior judicial analyst Andrew Napolitano said the entire chain of command involved in the boat strike “should be prosecuted for a war crime.”
Despite scattered criticisms, right-wing media have generally dismissed the accusations against Hegseth. Fox’s Jesse Watters called the story a “hoax” and Fox’s Greg Gutfeld said, “It’s just better for us to kill them in the ocean, make them shark feed, be done with it.”
Amid the outrage directed toward the Pentagon and Hegseth, right-wing commentators seized on a New York Times report about the September 2 attack, claiming the article “DEBUNKED” the Washington Post’s report. In reality, the Times actually confirmed, rather than undermined, the Post’s account. I invite you to read Media Matters’ breakdown of the articles showing how wrong right-wing media are on this narrative.
It’s worth noting here that Hegseth, before becoming secretary of defense, was a champion of war criminals. As a Fox News host in 2019, Hegseth defended an American soldier who admitted to the extrajudicial execution of an alleged Taliban bombmaker, saying, “If he committed premeditated murder … then I did as well. What do you think you do in war?” Hegseth also used his position at Fox to endorse presidential pardons for U.S. service members accused or convicted of war crimes.