After Fox News promoted a hoax about homeless veterans being “evicted” from New York hotels to house migrants last year, some of the network’s anchors said they would provide more information “as we get it.” That promise was apparently disingenuous: Fox has yet to report that the originator of the bogus story now faces federal fraud charges.
On May 12, 2023, New York Post printed a story that claimed that nearly two dozen homeless veterans were kicked out of hotels in upstate New York to make room for migrants. The report cited Army veteran Sharon Toney-Finch, whose foundation claims to “help homeless and low-income military service veterans in need of living assistance,” as its source. The story became a cause celebre for right-wing commentators seeking to demonize migrants and Democratic politicians. But within days Toney-Smith’s tale collapsed when local news outlets reported that she had fabricated the entire story — the displaced homeless veterans never existed.
A few days ago, federal prosecutors charged Toney-Finch with multiple counts of fraud. They allege that she raised funds for her foundation by falsely claiming to have received a Purple Heart after surviving a terrorist attack and spent the group’s money on personal expenses. Prosecutors also allege that she received “hundreds of thousands of dollars in disability benefits” by falsifying her military discharge paperwork to match her story.
As Toney-Finch’s story unraveled last May, Fox personalities began backtracking on the bogus story, with some Fox figures admitting — in strikingly similar on-air statements — that they had been duped and promised to update viewers with more information “as we get it.”
Yet none of them have mentioned that the “veterans advocate” behind the story is facing criminal charges for fraud.