Right-wing media’s story keeps changing in order to falsely accuse U.S. women’s soccer team of disrespecting a veteran

No matter which way the women face, right-wing media will trash America’s team

Right-wing media are circulating a false claim about what should have simply stood as a touching moment, when a 98-year-old World War II veteran played the national anthem at the start of a U.S. women’s soccer game.

But in the telling of right-wing media outlets, players were either disrespectfully turning away to the side — or disrespectfully facing forward. Either way, they say, it was bad.

Turning to the side was “disgraceful”

This started with a tweet Monday night from far-right site The Post-Millennial, denouncing the “disgraceful behaviour from some members of the U.S. Women's National Team as they turn their backs” on DuPré.

However, as team member Carli Lloyd replied, the players who turned were in fact facing the American flag during the anthem.

The U.S. Soccer Federation tweeted back: “Not true. No one turned their back on WWII Veteran Pete DuPré during tonight's anthem. Some USWNT players were simply looking at the flag on a pole in one end of the stadium.” The U.S. Soccer Women’s National Team account also tweeted a video of team members greeting DuPré after the game and signing a ball for him:

Fox News Radio host Guy Benson, for example, castigated “the handful of ingrates who turned away as he performed.” Right-wing provocateur Dinesh D’Souza also accused the players of having “turned away as 98-year-old WWII vet played the national anthem.”

Facing forward was “disrespectful,” too

However, right-wing media outlets also came up with a narrative by which team members facing forward, in the direction of DuPré’s harmonica playing, was a similarly monstrous act.

In a perfect example of this heads-I-win-tails-you-lose approach, Newsmax’s Wake Up America host Rob Finnerty on Tuesday morning attacked two team members, both women of color, for actually facing forward in the direction of DuPré playing his harmonica.

“Two of the players, Crystal Dunn and Christen Press, appear to be turning their backs on the American flag while Pete DuPré, a 98-year-old World War II veteran — there’s the two soccer players right there, you see the rest of the soccer team is facing one direction,” said Finnerty. “They’re facing toward the flag. Those two players right there, Crystal Dunn, Christen Press, are facing away from the flag.”

Panel member Amy Tarkanian then called the two team members “a couple of disrespectful punks, and that’s putting it nicely,” for purportedly disrespecting the sacrifices of veterans. “And the fact that those two women are even allowed and given the freedom to play their sport of choice, they should be thanking their lucky stars and kissing the ground, and thanking that 98-year-old veteran for them being able to do whatever it is that they would like to do.”

Video file

Citation From the July 6, 2021, edition of Newsmax’s Wake Up America

An online article from Newsmax also accused Dunn and Press of having “protested” the 98-year-old veteran’s rendition of the anthem. In addition, a tweet from former Trump administration official and current Newsmax commentator Richard Grenell accused the two players of having “turned away” from both the flag and the elderly veteran.

screen grab

Just to be clear on this point again: Dunn, Press, and other players who faced forward were looking at DuPré, while the other team members who faced to the side were looking at an American flag.

Indeed, even The Post-Millennial has altered its own headline to reflect the changing reasons for condemning the players.

The point of right-wing media’s manufactured outrage is just to trash the American women’s team

Fox News has long attacked athletes for kneeling during the national anthem, in protests over racial inequality — so much so, that the network once falsely used other photos of players who were actually praying during a game. And this pattern continued on Fox’s purported “straight news” program America’s Newsroom on Tuesday, when co-anchor Dana Perino spoke with Fox Bet sports host Clay Travis about this video.

While Perino gave the explanation that players were facing a flag, Travis then chimed in to essentially declare the players guilty by accusation, blaming them for the fact that people would be saying such a thing about them in the first place.

Video file

Citation From the July 6, 2021, edition of Fox News’ America’s Newsroom

DANA PERINO (CO-ANCHOR): There's this dust-up over the U.S. women’s soccer team. There are some people who think that there were members of the team who were turning away from the flag and the anthem that was being played there. But then the U.S. Soccer team said, no, actually, that’s not true, some people were just looking at the different flag that was there. Carli Lloyd, she’s a midfielder, she said, “We turned because we faced the flag,” and she gave a little flag emoji. I know I watched the video, I feel like maybe that makes sense to me. But what did you see?

CLAY TRAVIS (FOX BET LIVE HOST): Well, first of all, congratulations to the 98-year-old World War II veteran who played the national anthem so beautifully before this game. I think he deserves an awful lot of commendation, credit, and applause from everybody out there for what he did in the past and also what he did just yesterday.

But I think this is, Dana, emblematic of where we are with sports now, where a huge percentage of American sports fans totally think it's believable that the U.S. women's soccer team would turn their back on a 98-year-old World War II veteran as he plays the national anthem, and not even think twice about it.

I, like you, Dana, watched this video. I think it’s a little bit confusing, they weren’t all faced in the same direction. And I think it is unfortunately a sign of where we are as a country that so many of us just presume that that level of disrespect is occurring by our national teams during the anthem.

TRAVIS: Remember, the IOC, the International Olympic Committee, has forbidden all political displays, and many people all over the world, if they made a political statement during the anthem, would be executed back in their home countries if they were being negative in that way. It’s a sign of our freedoms that our people are doing it. Unfortunately, it becomes propaganda for our enemies, particularly in China.

At the end of the segment, Perino remarked that Travis had “made some great points there.”

Fox’s website also posted an article seemingly debunking the fake outrage — in addition to carrying the league’s explanation, the article notes that Dunn was among the players who later greeted DuPré and autographed the ball for him.

However, Fox’s homepage simply carries more right-wing clickbait with the heading “Video Sparks Outrage” — that is, fake outrage.

screen grab