Skip to main content

Trending

  • Ukraine
  • January 6th attack
  • Abortion rights & access

Social Media Menu

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Utility Navigation

  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate

Media Matters for America

Main navigation

  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives

Media Matters for America

  • Nav
  • Search

Main navigation

  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives

Trending

  • Ukraine
  • January 6th attack
  • Abortion rights & access

Utility Navigation

  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate

Social Media Menu

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
Newspapers on a purple background

Ceci Freed / Media Matters

Another day of irresponsible Ukraine headlines shows mainstream media still don't get it

Written by Parker Molloy

Published 10/04/19 5:03 PM EDT

Share

  • Email
  • Twitter
  • Facebook
  • Print

Comment

  • Comments

There’s nothing wrong with New York Times reporter Andrew Kramer’s October 4 report about a new development in the scandal surrounding President Donald Trump’s attempts to coerce Ukraine into carrying out a politically motivated investigation.

But there was something wrong with the headline.

Kramer’s article explained that the Ukrainian government would audit a closed case involving a gas company linked to Hunter Biden, the son of Democratic 2020 presidential candidate and former Vice President Joe Biden. It also, crucially, reiterated that there’s “no evidence of wrongdoing” by the Bidens, and that Trump is facing an impeachment inquiry over the pressure he put on the Ukrainian government to investigate the Bidens and the withholding of foreign aid as leverage, which are possible abuses of power.

The article’s headline, however, painted a different picture, reading “Ukraine to Review Criminal Case on Owner of Firm Linked to Biden’s Son.” When detached from Trump’s push for a frivolous investigation, this headline, which was later slightly altered, hints that there’s reason to suspect the Bidens of wrongdoing. (This likely isn’t Kramer’s fault; reporters rarely write their own headlines.)

x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
The New York Times: "Ukraine to Review Criminal Case on Owner of Firm Linked to Biden's Son"

No journalist wants thousands of their words to be reduced to a single sentence, but that’s the current state of media. No amount of good reporting will make up for the damage of a terrible headline. A 2014 American Press Institute study found that 60% of those surveyed said that they hadn’t read past the headline of a single story in the week prior. That means that if pertinent information isn’t actually in the headline, the majority of people won’t know it even exists.

This problem isn’t limited to the Times, either. Several other outlets ran with the story, giving Trump exactly the headline he wanted.

CNN, USA Today, CBS, Forbes, The Wall Street Journal, and NBC also ran headlines that hinted at impropriety on the Bidens’ part. In each instance, these headlines could have been made more accurate by simply adding phrases like “caving to Trump pressure.”

x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
CNN: "Ukraine will review probe into gas company linked to Biden's son"
USA Today: Ukraine to review investigation of company tied to Hunter Biden
CBS: Ukraine to review cases into firm linked to Hunter Biden
Forbes: "Ukraine To Review Criminal Cases Possibly Linked To Bidens"
The Wall Street Journal: "Ukraine to Review Investigations Into Firm Linked to Biden's Son"
NBC: "Ukraine to review investigations into owner of company that employed Biden's son"

The most damaging instance of this problem is perhaps a headline by The Associated Press. Because thousands of news outlets run content that the AP pushes out on the wire, its story and similar headlines ended up at Politico, PBS, ABC, The Washington Post, Time, and HuffPost, among many other local, national, and international outlets.

x (x)
 
x (x)
 
x (x)
 
The Associated Press: "Ukraine reviews cases on owner of firm that hired Biden son"

News organizations need to do a bit of soul-searching to rethink their objectives and update their strategy moving forward.

MSNBC’s Chris Hayes spoke too soon when he tweeted that if Trump’s attempts to extort Ukraine into investigating Hunter Biden hadn’t been exposed, we would’ve seen stories with headlines like “BIDEN SON UNDER INVESTIGATION, UKRAINE PROSECUTOR SAYS.” Just hours later, those headlines actually began rolling in.

x (x)
 
x (x)
 

The most important point in Hayes’ tweet is the accurate appraisal of what successful corruption looks like in 2019, a year in which just four in 10 Republicans believe Trump asked the Ukrainian president to investigate the son of his potential 2020 election opponent -- even though Trump himself has admitted that he did. 

Success in the current media landscape is about narratives built around headlines. To rebuild trust in media, it’s time to rethink headlines and news delivery systems as a whole. In the meantime, publishers committed to informing the public need to understand the implications of their decisions around framing the story.

x (x)
 

The Latest

  1. Lara Trump: “People are advocating for you to have an abortion as opposed ... to giving you the choice to choose whatever you want”

    Video & Audio 06/26/22 6:01 PM EDT

  2. Fox host criticizes “the eugenics mentality of the pro-choice movement”

    Video & Audio 06/26/22 11:27 AM EDT

  3. Mark Levin downplays Roe decision: “Really Roe v. Wade wasn't overturned”

    Video & Audio 06/26/22 11:08 AM EDT

  4. Fox News coverage of Roe being overturned featured a lot of men

    Article 06/24/22 11:01 PM EDT

  5. On Fox News, Lila Rose likens “pro-abortion advocates” to Nazis

    Video & Audio 06/24/22 9:23 PM EDT

Pagination

  • Current page 1
  • …
  • Next page ››

In This Article

  • Trump impeachment

    Trump Impeachment Inquiry
Comments
0 Comments
Share Count
0 Shares

Related

  1. Fox News’ Martha MacCallum praises Zelensky in comparison to Biden — after previously defending Trump’s extortion of the Ukrainian president

    Article 03/01/22 4:15 PM EST

  2. Wash. Post’s Hugh Hewitt and Fox News’ Mike Pompeo lie about Trump’s extortion of Ukraine

    Article 02/28/22 5:16 PM EST

  3. Flashback: Sean Hannity spent months aggressively defending President Trump for withholding military aid from Ukraine

    Article 02/25/22 10:56 AM EST

Media Matters for America

Footer menu

  • About
  • Contact
  • Corrections
  • Submissions
  • Jobs
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions

Social Media Menu

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

© 2022 Media Matters for America