Tuesday saw Democrats sweep several major elections across the country. After facing extreme attacks by right-wing media, Zohran Mamdani was elected mayor in New York City. Democrats also won gubernatorial elections in Virginia and New Jersey (more on New Jersey in a moment). Many right-wing pundits responded to the losses with despair. A Newsmax host, for example, told his colleagues “it’s like a funeral in here,” while a Daily Wire host acknowledged, “We got blown out of the water.” Discussing President Donald Trump’s absence from ballots in off-year elections, podcaster Megyn Kelly said: “Republicans can’t win without big daddy? … Then you’re going to lose forever because he can’t run again.”
People more qualified than me can speak to the underlying causes which drove the election results. But I would point to just one issue — Trump has repeatedly and falsely claimed that grocery and food prices were supposedly decreasing during his second term in office, and right-wing media have been helping him peddle this falsehood. In the month of October, Fox News and Fox Business spent just 1 hour and 23 minutes discussing high and rising grocery prices — that’s less than 1 ½ minutes per day on average. Despite that, on the morning after the elections, a Fox anchor reported that “71% of people … said they are spending more on groceries now than a year ago.” Later that day, Fox’s Bret Baier summed up the issue well when he said, “This dichotomy between how Wall Street is doing and how big business is doing and how you feel about it at home is something Republicans really have to look at closely.”
In the wake of Tuesday’s elections, right-wing media have started to acknowledge that Trump and the Republican-controlled Congress have failed to address the growing affordability crisis in the United States.
The New Jersey gubernatorial election deserves some attention because Fox’s Sean Hannity made this race a special project for himself. Hannity spent weeks urgently focusing the attention of his viewers on the New Jersey race, interviewing Republican candidate Jack Ciattarelli multiple times, and campaigning for him. After Fox called the race for Democratic candidate Mikie Sherrill, Hannity said the reason Ciattarelli lost was because too many Republicans left the state.
Of course, that view is hogwash. New Jersey’s election was not close in any way — Sherrill ended up winning by a dominant 56% to 43% margin. What a Trumpist zealot like Hannity cannot accept is the possibility that voters have soured on Trump and are punishing Republicans up and down the ticket for his economic failures, corruption, malfeasance, and authoritarian conduct.
- Also: Media Matters' Ari Drennen reviews why right-wing media's anti-trans gambit failed in 2025.