Skip to main content
  • Online media
  • Tariffs
  • Jeanine Pirro
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate

Media Matters for America

  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives

Media Matters for America

  • Nav
  • Search
  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives
  • Online media
  • Tariffs
  • Jeanine Pirro
  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
Fox News

Images via Fox News

Three things you probably missed about the fencing tournament Fox News has been targeting

The female fencer who forfeited a match against her trans opponent competed in a coed tournament just one week before

Special Programs LGBTQ

Written by Pete Tsipis & Alyssa Tirrell

Published 04/14/25 4:34 PM EDT

Late last month, fencer Stephanie Turner took a knee rather than compete against trans opponent Red Sullivan and was disqualified from the University of Maryland's Cherry Blossom tournament. The event sparked a campaign on Fox News, filled with anti-trans bigotry but lacking key context, and eventually prompted both federal and state investigations into USA Fencing's trans-inclusive policy. The Department of Education's investigation was announced during an interview with Education Secretary Linda McMahon on Fox News' Faulkner Focus, further underscoring the network's role in promoting the incident. 

Here are three things you might have missed about the fencers, the tournament, and right-wing media's role in driving the backlash: 

  • Turner competed in a coed tournament just seven days before she refused to spar with a trans opponent. Previously reported in Rolling Stone, Turner finished in eighth place out of 32 fencers at the Swarthmore College Phoenix Cup C & Under tournament, where she competed, and won, against multiple male fencers in the mixed foil event. During the course of that tournament, Turner, 31, also had bouts against teenage and college club opponents. 
  • Sullivan finished 24th out of 39 fencers in the all-women's event that prompted controversy. Sullivan lost four of her six bouts in the women’s foil event, as previously reported in Rolling Stone. Earlier this year at the USA Fencing 2025 Junior Olympics, she placed 172nd out of 246 fencers, losing five of her seven bouts in the junior women’s foil event.
  • Following the forfeit, Turner received $5,000 from anti-trans organization XX-XY. XX-XY CEO Jennifer Sey announced that Turner would be honored as a “Courage Wins Champion” and awarded the sum during an interview on Fox News. XX-XY has been endorsed by former NCAA swimmer Riley Gaines, who has been a longtime proponent of trans exclusion in women's sports and beyond. In addition to her partnership with XX-XY, Gaines hosts her own show on Fox News’ sports outlet, OutKick, where she has promoted her exclusionary views and targeted trans athletes. 

In spite of all this, Fox News hosts and guests have promoted backlash against Sullivan, deploying anti-trans rhetoric and using the case to urge further exclusion of trans athletes. 

  • Turner gave an interview on America Reports, where she spoke about her forfeit. Despite her history of coed competition, Turner told co-host John Roberts, “I am a woman, and I have an athletic disadvantage to men, so I compete in the women's division, which is where I rightfully am." Turner added that she knew Sullivan was trans because she recognized the name from Reduxx, an outlet that had published a “hit piece” on the athlete's identity. [Fox News, America Reports, 4/3/25; Rolling Stone, 4/12/25]
  • Gaines appeared on America's Newsroom, where she praised Turner's forfeit. Gaines falsely stated that the competition was a “junior women’s olympic qualifying event,” adding, “It’s the pinnacle of their sport at this point.” The tournament was a regional event that had no ties to the Olympics, as Turner stated on America Reports. [Fox News, America's Newsroom, 4/3/25; Fox News, America Reports, 4/3/25]
  • On Outnumbered, Fox contributor Nicole Saphier suggested that Sullivan transitioned solely for an alleged competitive advantage, saying, “These men can't cut it with the other male athletes, so therefore they are coming into the female sports.” Co-host Emily Campagno added that there should be a “full house cleaning” of “sports that are letting biological men compete with women.” [Fox News, Outnumbered, 4/3/25]
  • On The Five, co-host Dana Perino said she was “disgusted” that USA Fencing had, in co-host Jesse Watters' words, “backed the man.” She said of Turner, “I think it's horrible that she has to be the most courageous person compared to all these other women athletes who have succeeded and are now in retirement with all of their millions.” [The Five, Fox News, 4/3/25]
  • Host Jesse Watters praised Turner, saying that she wouldn't let her opponent “get off on his little fetish.” Watters also mistakenly referred to Turner as a “collegiate fencer.” Turner, 31, is not affiliated with a college or university. [Fox News, Jesse Watters Prime Time, 4/5/25]
  • On America's Newsroom, guest and Fox anchor Martha MacCallum praised Turner, calling her “courageous.” Co-host Dana Perino expressed dismay that older athletes were not making exclusionary statements and said young competitors “are not being backed up by the very women who wanted Title IX in the first place.” [Fox News, America's Newsroom, 4/9/25]

Amid the backlash, USA Fencing stood by its trans-inclusive policies which require “one calendar year (12 months) of testosterone suppression treatment” for athletes assigned male at birth who wish to compete in the women's category. A USA Fencing spokesperson told Fox News that Turner's disqualification had nothing to do with her protest of the policy, saying, “In the case of Stephanie Turner, her disqualification was not related to any personal statement but was merely the direct result of her decision to decline to fence an eligible opponent, which the FIE rules clearly prohibit.” Sullivan told Rolling Stone that the broader fencing community had also been supportive amid the backlash. 

The campaign against USA Fencing and Sullivan has already had real-world consequences. Both Texas Attorney General Ken Paxton and Secretary of Education Linda McMahon have announced investigations into the incident. 

The Latest

  1. Sean Hannity attacks Pope Leo XIV for believing there’s nothing Christian about warehousing immigrant children in cages

    Video & Audio 05/08/25 5:05 PM EDT

  2. Jack Posobiec criticizes Pope Leo XIV for “promoting anti-Trump and anti-Bukele articles regarding the deportations of criminal illegals”

    Video & Audio 05/08/25 3:43 PM EDT

  3. Newsmax's Rick Santorum criticizes Pope Leo XIV for using “buzzwords of the left”

    Video & Audio 05/08/25 2:57 PM EDT

  4. Charlie Kirk: “Mr. Prevost, the new pope, was retweeting George Floyd propaganda”

    Video & Audio 05/08/25 2:30 PM EDT

  5. Fox News host doesn't remember “anyone in President Trump's orbit bringing up the race of Kamala Harris”

    Video & Audio 05/08/25 2:28 PM EDT

Pagination

  • Previous page ‹‹
  • …
  • Current page 2
  • …
  • Next page ››

In This Article

  • Fox News

    Fox-News-MMFA-Tag.png

Related

  1. Fox News outstripped CNN and MSNBC in first month covering Trump's anti-trans executive orders

    Research/Study 03/11/25 12:02 PM EDT

  2. Right-wing media revive manufactured Olympic controversy in push to expand trans athlete bans, label intersex women as “males”

    Article 03/13/25 12:25 PM EDT

  3. OutKick contributor Riley Gaines cheers as college volleyball teams forfeit matches against alleged trans competitor

    Article 10/09/24 11:08 AM EDT

Media Matters for America

Sign up for email updates
  • About
  • Contact
  • Corrections
  • Submissions
  • Jobs
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS

© 2025 Media Matters for America

RSS