Skip to main content
  • Online media
  • Tariffs
  • Jeanine Pirro
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate

Media Matters for America

  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives

Media Matters for America

  • Nav
  • Search
  • News & Analysis
  • Research & Studies
  • Audio & Video
  • Archives
  • Online media
  • Tariffs
  • Jeanine Pirro
  • Take Action
  • Search
  • Donate
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS
Molly Butler / Media Matters

CNN is relitigating Harris' position on fracking, again

Right-wing media figures attempt to weaponize claims that Harris walked back her support for fracking

Special Programs Climate & Energy

Written by Allison Fisher

Research contributions from Ilana Berger

Published 10/23/24 3:08 PM EDT

Referencing a PoliticoPro article, a CNN KFILE reporter suggested in an October 21 post that Vice President Kamala Harris’ campaign is “walking back her support for fracking” because “a top climate campaign staffer told PoliticoPro notes she's not promoting expanding it and said she didn't promote increased leases for fracking in the Inflation Reduction Act.”

Right-wing media figures have latched on to the idea that Harris flipped her position on fracking and no longer supports the controversial drilling technique.

In response to the post, the climate campaign staffer clarified:

“I didn't explain myself clearly here. Contrary to Trump's claims, the VP has not banned fracking, doesn't support banning fracking, and in fact cast the tie-breaking vote on the biggest pro-climate law ever, which, yes, opened new fracking leases. People know that's her position.”

KFILE reposted the clarification to the original post. But even without the clarification, it is not contradictory for a presidential candidate to both oppose a total ban on fracking — the majority of which happens on state and private land — and oppose expanding fracking on federal land. If anything, it's wholly representative of the Harris-Biden approach to oil and gas, which has attempted to balance the upheaval of the global fossil fuel market in the wake of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine and America’s own transition to a clean energy economy.

Notably, the post comes on the heels of an October 15 report from KFILE, which suggested that Harris has abandoned her progressive position on climate change. The claim was evidenced by, among other things, the fact that she no longer supports a ban on fracking, a position she held during the 2019 Democratic primary but changed after becoming vice president.

Right-wing media latch on to suggestion that Harris is walking back her “support for fracking”

Right-wing media have played a significant role in elevating the issue of fracking over the last several presidential election cycles, even as its significance to most Pennsylvanians has waned. This latest attempt to redefine Harris’ position provided an opening for right-wing media figures to push the false narrative that support for fracking is a litmus test for the presidency, and that Harris is failing it.

  • Turning Point USA founder and right-wing radio host Charlie Kirk posted on X: “Kamala campaign aides are now trying to walk back her recent switch to supporting fracking, saying she ‘is not promoting expansion’ and conceding only that she won't ban it. Did Kamala just throw away Pennsylvania to placate the radical left?” [X, 10/21/24]
  • The Daily Wire founder Ben Shapiro: “Remember the time that Kamala Harris said she was anti-fracking and then came forward and said she was pro-fracking? Well, now apparently, they’re now walking back their support for fracking again.” [The Daily Wire, The Ben Shapiro Show, 10/21/24]
  • Jack Clark, a senior fellow at the Project 2025-affiliated Center for Renewing America wrote: “This is very important. Kamala flip flopping on fracking back to not supporting it.” [X, 10/21/24; CNN, 8/15/2024]
  • Fox host Sean Hannity promoted the idea that Harris has walked back her position on fracking on both his website and his Fox News prime-time show, claiming on Hannity: “Harris is clearly trying to have it both ways” on fracking. [Hannity.com, 10/21/24; Fox News, Hannity, 10/21/24]
  • Co-founder of right-wing outlet The Leading Report Patrick Webb wrote: “BREAKING: Kamala Harris no longer supports fracking, according to campaign aide.” [X, 10/21/24]
  • Conservative commentator Erick Erickson amplified the claim in a clip from his show on X, saying, “The Kamala Harris campaign appears to be walking back its support for fracking.” “Can those of you in Pennsylvania really trust Kamala Harris?” he later said. “She’s been lying about her fracking position.” [X, 10/21/24]
  • Right-wing outlet Breitbart wrote that the climate campaign staffer “walking back Vice President Kamala Harris’s unconditional support for fracking … underscores claims made by critics that Harris is an empty political shell with intentions to do or say whatever is needed to get elected.” [Breitbart, 10/21/24]
  • Fox & Friends highlighted the U.S. Oil and Gas Association’s response to allegations that Harris walked back her position, noting that the trade group posted on X: “Wait! change of plan from earlier this morning.… As of this afternoon, Harris now supports fracking which is a change of position from this morning in which they opposed fracking…. Which was a change from the July position in which they supported fracking…. Which was a change from their June position in which they…. Opposed fracking. Got it? Got it.” [Fox News, Fox & Friends, 10/22/24]
  • The following day, Fox & Friends hosted Tim Stewart, president of the U.S. Oil and Gas Association. Stewart claimed to still be “confused” about Harris’ position on fracking before making a misleading claim about how many jobs the industry supports in Pennsylvania: “If everybody is confused, we are all confused, and I think Steve, if you look at it, there are 425,000 jobs in Pennsylvania. … I think they took a look at that and said, huh, well we got to tell all these people … that depend upon the industry they’re important until the election.” According to a fact check on fracking jobs, “The state of Pennsylvania reported about 26,000 direct jobs in the oil and gas industry in 2020, less than 1% of all jobs in the state. Four years later, that number is even smaller.” [Fox News, Fox & Friends, 10/23/24; WHYY.org, 9/13/24]

The debate around Harris’ position on fracking is missing critical context

On October 15, CNN’s KFILE published a report claiming Harris has changed her position on climate change, saying that she has “abandoned a number of progressive positions” that she held in 2019, including positions related to the Green New Deal and her support for a fracking ban, while now touting record U.S. oil and gas production on the campaign trail.

The report on how Harris’ climate and energy positions have changed in the past 5 years only mentioned in passing how the climate and energy landscape itself has changed in the past 5 years — and Harris’ role in that change.

KFILE senior editor Andrew Kaczynski discussed these already well-litigated points on the October 16 edition of CNN's Erin Burnett OutFront.

During the OutFront segment, anchor Erin Burnett also asked Arizona Mayor John Giles to respond to the question of Harris' supposed flip-flop on fracking. In his response, he identified part of the missing context: “She has evolved as a government official. I think the last four years where she was riding shotgun with Joe Biden responding to world crises and domestic issues have been tremendously valuable and her evolution as a leader.”

Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in February 2022 had a huge impact on global energy supply, resulting in record gas prices in the U.S. (which both hurt American consumers and drove up inflation) and increased demand in Europe. 

As the New York Times reported in February, “Europe has become the biggest importer of American gas in recent years, enabling the continent to slash by more than half its reliance on Russian gas since Russia’s invasion of Ukraine in 2022. In the future, Europe is expected to curb its appetite for gas by adding more renewable energy sources like wind and solar power.” 

And while the U.S. has increased production in response to these global challenges, in January the Biden-Harris administration paused permitting “new facilities that export liquefied natural gas in order to study their impact on climate change, the economy and national security” and put “forward several new regulations on methane from gas production.”

In August 2022, the administration signed into law the largest investment in climate solutions in U.S. history as part of the Inflation Reduction Act, which Harris cast the tie-breaking vote to pass. This fact was left out of the KFILE report, but seems material to her climate change position.

Finally, it's worth noting that the national media obsession with Harris’ evolving position on fracking is bizarre, not only because it discounts the landscape her position evolved in, but because it seems to willfully avoid the fact that presidents cannot ban fracking on the state and private land where the vast majority of drilling is done. It also assumes that supporting fracking is a litmus test for Pennsylvania voters. In fact, support for fracking in Pennsylvania is not universal. The industry has not delivered the wealth it promised and has shed “thousands of workers in the state since 2019," while many who live in the shadow of fracking infrastructure are dealing with contaminated water and health impacts. 

The Latest

  1. WSJ pundits demolish right-wing talking points defending Hegseth: “It all comes back again to this basic point that something's wrong at the top levels”

    Video & Audio 04/24/25 1:02 PM EDT

  2. Daily Wire host says Pete Buttigieg is in a “pretend” marriage and “refuses to get married and make a baby the old-fashioned way”

    Video & Audio 04/24/25 10:56 AM EDT

  3. Michael Knowles: “Do your patriotic duty. Make America great again. You gotta have babies. OK? It's your marital duty. It's your patriotic duty.”

    Video & Audio 04/24/25 10:33 AM EDT

  4. YouTube content creators have earned more than 200 million views on videos of their visits to El Salvador’s CECOT prison

    Narrative/Timeline 04/24/25 10:01 AM EDT

  5. Newsmax guest: “Trump doesn't understand who pays the tariffs. ... They're paid for by the middle class and the poor.”

    Video & Audio 04/24/25 9:17 AM EDT

Pagination

  • Previous page ‹‹
  • …
  • Current page 19
  • …
  • Next page ››

In This Article

  • CNN

    CNN-MMFA-Tag.png
  • Fox News

    Fox-News-MMFA-Tag.png

Related

  1. Interviewing Sen. John Fetterman, Meet the Press host repeats misleading industry claim about fracking jobs in Pennsylvania

    Article 09/23/24 3:24 PM EDT

  2. Fox & Friends host pushes wildly inflated Pennsylvania fracking jobs estimate

    Article 09/19/24 2:46 PM EDT

  3. CNN's Bill Weir challenges the media narrative that fracking is a presidential litmus test while highlighting its health impacts on PA communities

    Article 09/13/24 10:12 AM EDT

Media Matters for America

Sign up for email updates
  • About
  • Contact
  • Corrections
  • Submissions
  • Jobs
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Twitter
  • YouTube
  • RSS

© 2025 Media Matters for America

RSS