​Watch this MSNBC host slam the Trump administration's attempt to exaggerate claims of asylum fraud at the border

​Watch this MSNBC host slam the Trump administration's attempt to exaggerate claims of asylum fraud at the border

Stephanie Ruhle explains that less than 1 percent of families apprehended at the border aren't genuine families


​From the June 19 edition of MSNBC's MSNBC Live with Velshi and Ruhle:​

Loading the player reg...

STEPHANIE RUHLE (HOST): ​​DHS Secretary Kirst​j​en Nielsen, we've been saying her name a lot these days. She's justifying family separation by saying there​ i​s a huge jump in smugglers and gang members using kids unrelated to them to try to get inside the U.S. But​ Ms. Nielsen,​ I hope you're watching​.​ For fact's sake, you need to know ​some ​context. Here is specifically what ​S​ecretary Nielsen said at yesterday's ​W​hite ​H​ouse briefing.

​KIRSTJEN NIELSEN (SECRETARY OF HOMELAND SECURITY): In the last five months we've had​ a​ 314​ percent​ increase in adults and children arriving at the border fraudulently claiming to be a family unit.

​RUHLE: Come on, now. The Washington ​P​ost points out this is actually a ​teeny ​tiny fraction of the families apprehended during that time period. ​Listen up. ​In​ fiscal year​ 2017​,​ there were 46 cases where people falsely claimed the children they were​ travelling​ with were​ actually​ theirs. In the first five months of fiscal year 2018, there was 191 of these cases​,​ which is ​in fact ​an increase of 315​ percent​. Those numbers sound big, right?

But here's where the context couldn't be more important. In the first five months of this fiscal year, more than 31,000 families were a​pprehended at the border. ​So if we know 191 of them were fraudulent, that​ i​s less than 1​ percent​. To put it another way, for every 1,000 families who are approached at the border at that time, only 6 involved are pretending to be a child's parent. That is 6 out of 1,000. ​Six​ out of 1,000. It's like saying all homeless people must be drunks or broken out of an insane asylum. It's absurd.​


WashPost: How to mislead with statistics, DHS Secretary Nielsen edition


Myths and facts: Trump's separation of families and detention of children at the U.S.-Mexico border

On Fox, ICE director defends tearing asylum-seeking families apart using a misleading statistic on human smuggling

Fox & Friends host: "You can't even really blame an administration" for policy under Trump of separating parents from children at the border

Posted In
Government, Cabinet & Agencies, The Presidency & White House, Immigration, Border Security, Immigration Myths
Stephanie Ruhle
We've changed our commenting system to Disqus.
Instructions for signing up and claiming your comment history are located here.
Updated rules for commenting are here.