Fox News has repeatedly complained about legal immigrants using public services

Trump’s new public-charges rule against immigration grants Fox its wish

Tucker complaining about immigrants on welfare next to a photo of Donald Trump

On Monday, the Trump administration announced plans to “penalize legal immigrants who rely on public programs, such as food stamps and government-subsidized housing,” in an effort to cut back on legal immigration. Fox News has long complained about immigrants -- legal or otherwise -- benefiting from welfare programs. 

The New York Times says the rule will “provide the Trump administration a powerful new tool to narrow the demographic of people who come to live and work in the country.” The rule change comes as President Donald Trump is being criticized for promoting white supremacy talking points that revolve around a fear of white Americans being replaced by minority immigrants -- a theory that appears to have motivated a mass shooter to kill 22 people in El Paso, TX.

Fox News has long complained about both legal and undocumented immigrants receiving public benefits, insisting that benefits are being stolen from Americans.

Fox host Tucker Carlson applauded the Trump administration’s efforts to crack down on legal immigration through public charges laws, asserting that being on welfare is “not assimilation,” but “dependency.” Carlson asked why we would “import people from other countries on welfare,” calling the idea “insane.” [Tucker Carlson Tonight, 2/19/18]

Carlson complained about the perceived strain immigrants have on social programs, asking about what happens “when technology kills their jobs. ... So what do you do with hundreds of thousands of unemployed immigrant cab drivers? Do they all go on welfare?” [Tucker Carlson Tonight, 4/4/19]

On The Ingraham Angle, Fox host Jeanine Pirro asserted that “more than half of immigrant families use one or more welfare programs,” insisting that immigrants “should be adding to this country and not taking away.” [The Ingraham Angle, 8/8/18]

Video file

Citation The Ingraham Angle, 8/8/18

Carlson claimed the “overwhelming majority of these immigrants are on welfare,” adding that “Democrats long ago discovered that welfare is a handy vote-buying scheme.” [Tucker Carlson Tonight, 12/5/18]

Fox host Sean Hannity complained that “even those with legal green cards are tapping into welfare programs,” claiming this “puts a burden on our criminal justice system, educational system and health care system.” Hannity added, “Where is the sympathy for the American people,” who “deserve to be protected first.” [Hannity, 12/5/18]

Carlson complained that half of “legal immigrants, the best kind,” are on welfare, pointing out that “that’s well above the native average.” [Tucker Carlson Tonight, 12/4/18]

On Life, Liberty, and Levin, frequent Fox guest Heather Mac Donald complained about “unchecked, low-skilled immigration flow that is imposing enormous cost on the country in terms of welfare.” She chided immigrants that come from “largely peasant culture” and repeated that this is “costing taxpayers an enormous amount of money.” [Life, Liberty, and Levin, 12/2/18]

Video file

Citation Life, Liberty, and Levin, 12/2/18

On The Ingraham Angle, Fox guest Carrie Sheffield asked why “American taxpayers, the middle class families, the forgotten men and women of this country,” should be “forced to subsidize foreigners.” [The Ingraham Angle, 2/19/19]

Fox Business host Lou Dobbs claimed birthright citizenship led to an “explosion” of welfare in the 1960s. [Lou Dobbs Tonight, 11/1/18]

Carlson emphasized that the majority of immigrants “aren’t coming from South Asia. They’re coming from Latin America,” adding that “we have a right to ask questions about that.” [Tucker Carlson Tonight, 1/11/18]

Video file

Citation Tucker Carlson Tonight, 1/11/18