trump_jobs_3.png

Sarah Wasko / Media Matters

Research/Study Research/Study

Fox celebrates “amazing” April jobs report despite downward revisions

Fox pushed conspiracy theories in reaction to downward revisions under Biden

Fox News and Fox Business personalities gushed over the April jobs report from the Bureau of Labor Statistics, which beat expectations by showing an increase of 177,000 jobs last month while the unemployment rate remained unchanged at 4.2 percent. However, the jobs estimates for both February and March were revised down by a total of 58,000 jobs, and economists explained that the April report does not yet reflect the economic damage of President Donald Trump’s tariff policies.

The downward revisions contained in today’s release represent significant changes from initial estimates, which are always revised twice by the BLS before they are considered final. The April report also marked the third consecutive month that initial jobs estimates were revised down. Preliminary jobs reports for January (143,000 initial vs. 111,000 final), February (151,000 initial vs. 102,000 final), and March (228,000 initial vs. 185,000 revised) were all revised down as the Labor Department collected more survey data for each month. The April report — which, like last month’s, seems at first to exceed expectations — will be subject to the same revisions process.

Fox’s enthusiasm for the report stands in stark contrast to the network’s conspiracy theorizing over downward revisions to monthly jobs reports made during the Biden administration. And it’s not the first time the network has abandoned its conspiracy fixations with regard to monthly jobs data. Fox performed the same heel turn in the first few months of Trump’s first term in office.

  • Fox touts April jobs report containing downward revisions to February and March jobs estimates

    • Fox Business guest and Heritage Foundation economist Stephen Moore: “This is an amazing report.” Anchor Maria Bartiromo chimed in, “This proves Donald Trump’s point, that the economy is doing well.” At the end, Moore expressed relief that “the businesses are sticking with it and staying open.” [Fox Business, Mornings with Maria5/2/25]
    • Bartiromo: “The media can’t get out of its Trump derangement syndrome and just report the facts” on the economy. This followed Fox Business host Charles Payne arguing that the report ”proves we have an economy that all the experts continue to underestimate. … I think they’re looking through a prism of political hatred, for lack of a better term, rather than being logical about the greatest economy in the world.” [Fox Business, Mornings with Maria5/2/25]
    • Fox News anchor Bill Hemmer neglected to mention the most recent downward February and March revisions while highlighting previous estimates for those months and celebrating the April jobs report with White House Council of Economic Advisers Chairman Stephen Miran. Hemmer said: “Here is what happened in February and March. Added 117,000 in February, then you had 228,000 jobs that were added in March.” Hemmer did not mention the most recent downward revision of 58,000 jobs over those two months. [Fox News, America’s Newsroom5/2/25]
    • Fox & Friends co-host Brian Kilmeade: “The April jobs numbers report were released moments ago, and it is really, really good.” [Fox News, Fox & Friends5/2/25]
    • Fox Business anchor David Asman to Labor Secretary Lori Chavez-DeRemer: “Pretty good numbers.” Asman added: “Good news for those of us who believe that the government’s too big, that it needs to be shrunk, is that … the overall government job numbers, which includes state and local jobs, was up, but the federal government job numbers was down … by 9,000 jobs. That's good news. That shows that the work of DOGE and the work of the new administration is showing results.” [Fox Business, Varney & Co.5/2/25]
  • Fox pushed conspiracy theories in response to routine revisions to Biden’s monthly jobs reports

    • Stephen Moore: “These errors are not random when you have like 11 of the last 13 months that have been overestimates.” Moore continued: “Something is wrong with the way they’re … counting employment.” [Fox Business, Mornings with Maria9/6/24]
    • Fox host Sean Hannity cited standard revisions to claim Biden was “cooking the books” on positive jobs reports. Hannity said: “Looks to me like they might be artificially cooking the books, and then they — when they have the revisions, nobody pays attention to it. October revised from 150,000 to 105,000. November revised from 199 to 173 in total. These revisions, unemployment in October, that's nearly 100,000 lower than initially reported.” [Premiere Radio Networks, The Sean Hannity Show1/5/24]
    • David Asman claimed “somebody is fiddling with” jobs numbers because of downward revisions in 2023, saying, “They are playing some kind of game with the numbers here to make things at the moment look better than they really are.” [Fox News, The Ingraham Angle1/5/24]
    • Fox Business host and former Trump economic adviser Larry Kudlow also downplayed Biden’s positive jobs numbers by pointing to downward revisions, claiming “the economy is not as strong” as was thought. On-screen graphics during the segment read, “Numbers Behind Bidenomics Don’t Add Up,” and, “Fake Numbers, Fake Economy.” [Fox News, The Ingraham Angle1/8/24]
    • Fox Business host Brian Brenberg complained that negative job revisions had been “happening a lot lately” to downplay a positive Biden jobs report showing 209,000 jobs added. Brenberg said: “Everyone coming into this number thought we're going to have a big jobs number because we saw a big one from ADP earlier in the week. It came in low, but even more than that, previous months get revised down. That's been happening a lot lately, by the way.” [Fox News, Fox & Friends7/7/23]
  • Economists explain that the jobs report doesn’t yet reflect Trump’s most damaging policies, and the downward revisions show a weaker labor market

    • University of Michigan economist Justin Wolfers: “This is a reading largely from the pre-tariff period. Still very foggy about what lies ahead.” Wolfers added: “Revisions were somewhat worrying: March was revised down -43k to +185k. Feb down -15k to +102k.” [Bluesky, 5/2/255/2/25]
    • Wolfers: “It appears that most of the DOGE cuts have folks still on paid leave or getting severance pay, so they're not yet showing up in these numbers.” Wolfers added: “Hopefully the President will clarify later today if this is still the Biden economy,” apparently in reference to Trump blaming the economic contraction reported three days ago on former President Joe Biden. [Bluesky, 5/2/255/2/25; Media Matters, 5/1/25]
    • Moody’s Analytics chief economist Mark Zandi: “After accounting for downward revisions to previous months, employment was up only 119k. … Unless the trade war de-escalates in the next few weeks, the firewall will come down, and a recession will ensue.” [Twitter/X, 5/2/25]
    • University of Massachusetts Amherst economics professor Arindrajit Dube: “This is looking a bit in the rear view mirror, as the ‘reference week’ for this report - which is a jobs snapshot for that week - was prior to ‘liberation day.’” [Twitter/X, 5/2/25]
    • Yale Budget Lab director of economics Ernie Tedeschi: “-58K 2M revisions, so a net 119K jobs this month from what we thought last month. That would be a perfectly fine trend number if we knew there were no macroeconomic shocks on the horizon. Are there any current macroeconomic shocks we can think of?” [Twitter/X, 5/2/25]
    • Arkansas Center for Research in Economics Director Jeremy Horpedahl, referencing Fox conspiracy theories: “I guess they weren't just cooking the books for Biden. Jobs numbers continue to be revised downward under Trump.” [Twitter/X, 5/2/25]