Fox News Got Played On Benghazi By Its “Power Players Of The Week”

Fox News Sunday selected Victoria Toensing and Joseph diGenova, attorneys who represented witnesses at a Republican-led hearing on the attacks at a U.S. diplomatic facility in Benghazi, Libya, for its “power players of the week,” an unfortunate choice given that both individuals misled Fox News and its viewers about allegations of threats and intimidation against their clients and about efforts by the administration to prevent their clients from testifying.

Though Fox News Sunday aired certain aspects of Toensing and diGenova's biographies, the segment neglected to mention that the two have a history of poor professional conduct, including criticism from a Democratic congressman for inappropriate behavior and actions while they worked as congressional investigators due to their constant media appearances attacking President Clinton. They were also accused of having a conflict of interest for representing a Republican committee chairman under Justice Department investigation while simultaneously serving as special counsel to the committee in a separate investigation. More recently, Toensing pushed the false claim that outed CIA agent Valerie Plame had not been covert, in addition to other falsehoods.

On April 29, Fox's Special Report aired video of Toensing claiming that people who wanted to testify on Benghazi “have been threatened,” which Fox & Friends aired the following morning. Toensing was also cited by Special Report on April 29 in reporting the allegations that “the Obama administration is trying to intimidate potential whistleblowers into silence” and that possible witnesses were having their careers threatened. And a May 6 article by Fox Washington correspondents James Rosen and Chad Pergram sourced a claim that a witness named Mark Thompson “has been subjected to threats and intimidation by as-yet-unnamed superiors at State, in advance of his cooperation with Congress” to diGenova, who was representing Thompson.

But testimony by the witnesses at a GOP-led hearing on May 8 and subsequent interviews of their attorneys on Fox News revealed that Toensing and diGenova misled the network by claiming that their clients had suffered threats, intimidation, and orders to keep quiet. When asked on Fox's Your World on May 9 about claims that Thompson had been threatened, diGenova replied that Thompson “actually hasn't said that,” and explained that his client “didn't feel intimidated.”

Gregory Hicks, another witness at the hearing -- represented by Toensing -- explained under questioning that he had not been told not to speak to congressional investigators, only that he was required to have a State Department attorney present while doing so. Hicks also explained that, in contrast to claims that the administration tried to silence him, he was interviewed twice by the State Department's independent Accountability Review Board that was created to investigate the Benghazi attacks. Hicks' testimony further contradicted Toensing's April 29 claim to Special Report that careers were being threatened when he explained that “the overriding factor” in his determination to not return to his post in Libya was to remain with his family in the United States.