Major news organizations amplified Trump’s misinformation about Mueller's report
Twitter accounts of major national newspapers, cable, and broadcast news outlets spread -- without any context -- President Donald Trump's misinformation, outrageous characterizations of, and responses to special counsel Robert Mueller’s report on his Russia investigation.
Over the course of more than six days since news broke on March 22 that Mueller had delivered his report to Attorney General William Barr, the Twitter accounts of major national print, digital, wire, cable, and broadcast news outlets sent at least 45 tweets which parroted misinformation from Trump, his administration, or his campaign. Many of these tweets included quotes from the president which contained false information about the Mueller report and/or lacked the necessary context to fully inform any news consumers who get their news only via social media posts. And then there were other tweets that didn't contain misinformation, but instead failed to provide context to Trump’s answer to reporters about the Mueller report. Examples of the most glaring failures of these major news organizations are embedded below:
BREAKING: Pres. Trump tweets following Attorney General Barr's letter to Congress on Mueller report: “Complete and Total EXONERATION.” https://t.co/4Y4XCM9XsA pic.twitter.com/iEmZQB2dHZ
— ABC News (@ABC) March 24, 2019
As Barr explained in a letter he wrote to Congress summarizing Mueller’s findings, the report “does not exonerate” the president on whether he obstructed justice. Nevertheless, Twitter accounts of The Hill, CNN, The Washington Post, Vox, ABC News, ABC’s World News Tonight, ABC’s This Week, ABC Politics, NBC Politics, and Politico all repeated Trump’s false claim that the Mueller report is a “complete and total exoneration” of him.
President Trump: “The Mueller report was great. It could not have been better, it say no obstruction, no collusion. It could not have been better.” https://t.co/RVGbjjRvFr pic.twitter.com/SmaH5AiKlY
— The Hill (@thehill) March 27, 2019
Barr’s letter also explained that Mueller’s report left “unresolved whether the president's actions and intent could be viewed as obstruction.” Yet The Hill sent the same tweet three times uncritically repeating Trump’s claim that the Mueller report showed “no obstruction.”
Reporter: Do you think Special Counsel Mueller acted honorably?
President Trump: “Yes, he did. Yes, he did.” pic.twitter.com/IMW5lr4XgM
— NBC Nightly News with Lester Holt (@NBCNightlyNews) March 25, 2019
Many news outlets embedded a brief snippet of Trump responding affirmatively to a question about whether Mueller “acted honorably,” but failed to give basic context that Trump spent the last year savaging Mueller’s reputation by criticizing him, his actions, and his team. NBC Nightly News, NBC News, ABC’s World News Tonight, ABC News, ABC Politics, ABC’s This Week, MSNBC, NBC Politics, and NPR Politics all did this. The Hill tweeted Trump’s comment five times.
Breaking News: President Trump claimed “a complete and total exoneration” from the Mueller findings. “This was an illegal takedown that failed.” https://t.co/fcnmw9ZYyj
— The New York Times (@nytimes) March 24, 2019
President Trump says the Mueller investigation was an “attempted takeover of our government” https://t.co/Ns4Ey2FVww pic.twitter.com/2BhF0MpJ6d
— CNN (@CNN) March 28, 2019
Multiple news organizations also tweeted out Trump’s outrageous characterizations of Mueller’s investigation without any pushback. CBS News, The New York Times, and The Hill repeated Trump’s statement that the Mueller investigation was “an illegal takedown that failed.” CNN (twice), CNN's New Day, CNN Politics and MSNBC’s 11th Hour all repeated Trump’s quote that the Mueller investigation was an “attempted takeover of our government.”
Parroting Trump’s misinformation is an ongoing problem with major news outlets; in the 24 hours after Trump’s 2019 State of the Union address, 13 major news organizations wrote 49 tweets which promoted false or misleading comments from the president. It’s not enough for news organizations to fact-check and explain Trump’s comments in their articles. In this era of unprecedented lies from the president about virtually everything, news organizations must rethink how they draft their headlines and social media posts to make sure they include factual information in them.
It is possible to report on Trump’s misinformation and also provide context in the limited space of headlines and tweets. Here are some examples of tweets in which outlets did just that, thus providing accurate information to their audiences:
After Bill Barr's summary of the Mueller report was released, Trump tweeted: “No Collusion, No Obstruction, Complete and Total EXONERATION. KEEP AMERICA GREAT!”
Barr wrote in the summary that the Mueller report does not exonerate him on obstruction. https://t.co/UObtP6awTf
— Axios (@axios) March 24, 2019
President Trump is already claiming that Barr’s letter is a “COMPLETE AND TOTAL EXONERATION” proving there was “no obstruction.”
But it’s important to understand that Mueller didn’t draw that conclusion; Barr and Rosenstein did. https://t.co/qTy7tCnm9I
— Vox (@voxdotcom) March 24, 2019
Trump: “The Mueller report was great, it could not have been better. It said no obstruction, no collusion”
The letter from AG Barr says “while this report does not conclude that the President committed a crime, it also does not exonerate him” https://t.co/iGzcVqdti6 pic.twitter.com/jC2lRg6RVj
— CNN Politics (@CNNPolitics) March 26, 2019
“Do you think Robert Mueller acted honorably?” ABC News' @jonkarl asks.
“Yes, he did,” President Trump responds.
Trump has previously described special counsel Robert Mueller as “conflicted,” “disgraced” and a “liar" https://t.co/AC4uQJzwpj pic.twitter.com/TgXtlKWeDc
— This Week (@ThisWeekABC) March 26, 2019