Rob Reiner with Trump as his shadow

Andrea Austria / Media Matters

Here’s who is justifying Trump’s deranged response to Rob Reiner’s murder

President Donald Trump’s unhinged reaction to the stabbing deaths of Rob Reiner and his wife Michele Singer Reiner, which the president gleefully attributed to “the anger” the legendary director “caused others” via his anti-Trump activism in a Monday morning Truth Social post, triggered some of the most unified criticism from the right of Trump’s second term. 

On social media, conservative pundits and Fox News stars used words like “disgraceful,” “appalling,” “disgusting,” “unnecessary,” “inappropriate,” “gross,” “awful,” “cruel,” and “insane” to describe Trump gloating about brutal killings. CNN’s MAGA commentators, whose jobs depend on their willingness to defend the president at his most indefensible, were unwilling or unable to back Trump’s self-centered rantings about Reiner. On Fox, coverage of Trump’s comment was nearly nonexistent outside of Special Report; star host Jesse Watters gave a lengthy monologue about the killings and interviewed Reiner friend James Woods, but he aired Trump’s defense of his post without comment beyond noting, “Whoa.” 

While Trump has long demonstrated a near-pathological lack of empathy for those who don’t support him, the president’s suggestion that Reiner may have been killed alongside his wife in their home by someone he had “driven … CRAZY by his raging obsession of President Donald J. Trump” seemed to hit a nerve even among his supporters. Perhaps this is due to the tragic and deeply human circumstances of the Reiners’ deaths — their son, who has long struggled with drug addiction, is allegedly “responsible,” and was arrested Monday. 

But not everyone feels that way. A handful of prominent commentators on the right have risen in support of Trump’s Reiner remarks. 

They are justifying Trump’s “mean” comments on the grounds that Reiner is “a loser” who “spent a decade slandering” the president. They are praising Trump for being “very honest” and not “a phony.” They are arguing that complaining about it is stupid because Reiner’s leftist movement purportedly “wants us all dead.” And they are lashing out at those criticizing Trump, calling them “fake grifters” who are “whining like little bitches” about the president.

  • Jack Posobiec: “Not surprised Trump said what he said”

    MAGA streamer Jack Posobiec — whose 2024 book describes leftists as “unhumans” and was blurbed by Vice President JD Vance — was among those on the right who initially sought to use the Reiners’ deaths to seize the moral high ground. 

    “You won’t see people on the right celebrating the horrific murder of Rob Reiner and his wife,” Posobiec bragged on Sunday night, as news of their deaths circulated. “Compare to the Left’s reaction to Charlie Kirk’s murder,” he said, referencing random people who had their lives turned upside down for their social media reactions to that tragedy.

    But it’s dangerous to claim moral authority for your side when your standard-bearer is Trump. After the president weighed in, Posobiec pivoted, suggesting that it is appropriate to post mean things about someone if you had strong political differences. 

    “Rob Reiner called for Trump to be jailed over lies,” Posobiec wrote. “Not surprised Trump said what he said.”

    X post

    Posobiec subsequently mocked “people telling on themselves for crying over a mean Trump tweet,” finding Trump’s response acceptable because “the Left wants us all dead.”

  • Laura Loomer: “Trump is right.” Reiner is a “loser.”

    Laura Loomer, a fanatically loyal Trumpist with deep ties to the administration who is trying to foment an anti-Muslim crackdown, responded to Trump’s post by claiming that “Trump is right” because “Rob Reiner had a level of TDS that likely exuded a level of craziness around those he spent time with.”

    X post

    She also cited a fake post from Reiner, whom she described as a “loser,” and declared, “I stand with President Trump.” 

    X post

    And she lashed out at the “simps” and “fake grifters” who are “calling Trump out for speaking truth about Rob Reiner.”

    X post
  • Kurt Schlicter: Critics are “little bitches”

    Kurt Schlichter, the TownHall.com columnist and frequent guest host for Fox contributor Hugh Hewitt’s Salem Radio Network show, is perhaps best-known for his fantasies about a potential race war and other glorifications of political violence against the left. He repeatedly ranted on Monday about conservative pundits who criticized Trump over the Reiner remarks.

    “This Trump tweet about the guy who spent a decade slandering him in the most despicable ways possible provides the perfect opportunity for that kind of weak, feminine pseudo-conservative to do what they love best - join the left in whining like little bitches about how actual conservatives are so...so...soo...oh well I never!” he commented.

    X post

    After conservative pundit Erick Erickson commented that “the whole point should be that we are not them,” Schlichter responded that the right shouldn’t try to act like “good people” because the movement’s ends justify being “a bad person in the eyes of those too weak to stand and fight.”

    X post

    “Every tyranny in history embraced this,” Erickson responded.

  • Greg Gutfeld: “We don’t have to like it. I just look at [Trump’s] deeds.”

    When Democratic co-host Harold Ford Jr. mentioned Trump’s post on Monday’s edition of The Five and said that he hoped the president “corrects himself,” fellow co-host and notorious lacker-of-principles Greg Gutfeld rose to the challenge of explaining to viewers why what Trump says doesn’t matter. 

    “You don't have to like the things that he says all the time,” Gutfeld said. “It is why in my filter, Trump is always words versus deeds. I don't have to like what he says. In fact, I can hate what he says. But I can also think, in his brain, he is going, uh, this guy compared me to Hitler, he put a target on my back, I don't like him. And it’s like, well — if it were me I’d go, like, but I’m sorry he’s dead. But he can't let that go.”

    “We don't have to like it,” he concluded. “I just look at the deeds.”

  • Greg Kelly: “President Trump levels with us. He is not a phony”

    Newsmax host Greg Kelly, who has argued that Sen. Mark Kelly (D-AZ) “should be in jail” and that Jeffrey Epstein accomplice Ghislaine Maxwell “just might be innocent,” justified Trump’s Reiner comments on his Monday night broadcast. 

    Kelly drew a straight line between a clip he aired of Reiner criticizing Trump and the 2024 attempted assassination of Trump in Pennsylvania, commenting: “President Trump has every right, because he has a very unique perspective on all this stuff. Remember, this rhetoric led to an assassination attempt on him.” 

    Video file

    Citation

    From the December 15, 2025, edition of Newsmax's Greg Kelly Reports

  • Rob Finnerty: Trump is “human” and “very honest with the American people”

    Newsmax host Rob Finnerty, after reading Trump’s post on Monday’s show, said: “Donald Trump has posted thousands of times on Truth Social since he got back in office. You’re going to agree with some of them, you’re not going to agree with some of them, even if you support Donald Trump, and that should be OK. Was this post ill-timed, inelegant? Look, we will let you decide at home.”

    After noting that some Republicans had criticized Trump’s post, he added, “We’re not above criticizing the president on this show. But Donald Trump hated Rob Reiner, and Rob Reiner hated Donald Trump right back, and Donald Trump is human, he’s not a machine, he’s not perfect, but at least he is very honest with the American people.”

    Video file

    Citation

    From the December 15, 2025, edition of Newsmax's Finnerty

  • Mike Cernovich: “I do not give a fuck about trumps tweets”

    “I do not give a fuck about trumps tweets,” commented right-wing influencer Mike Cernovich. “I do care that doors haven’t been kicked in post Charlie Kirk assassination.”