Andrea Austria / Media Matters
Research/Study
“WE NEED MORE SLUT SHAMING:” Right-wing media react to the Cornell sexual assault case
Nick Fuentes: “Hypothetically, if a woman in your life was doing something like this, I would absolutely beat the fucking shit out of her”
Written by Isabella Sherk
Research contributions from Alyssa Tirrell & Reed McMaster
Published
Right-wing media are jumping at the chance to scrutinize a woman accusing seven men at Cornell University of rape. The woman, known to the public as Jane Doe, alleges seven men assaulted her in a fraternity house in 2024 while she was under the influence of alcohol and ketamine. The case received national media attention after Doe filed a civil lawsuit against her alleged attackers and Cornell.
Jump to section...
- Right-wing media figures spewed vitriol at Jane Doe, saying she “allowed herself to be treated like a sex doll,” is “not the most attractive gal,” and that she should “be put in jail”
- Figures on the right blamed “modern hookup culture” for sexual assaults and claimed we need to “roll back” or have a “reevaluation of” feminism, with some attempting to turn the matter into a debate about whether women have agency
- Others complained the defendants are facing a “Salem witch trial” or a “modern-day lynch mob”
-
Video file
-
Many right-wing media figures are claiming Doe “willingly walked into” a dangerous situation and that her reports to the police and subsequent civil suit were merely “a way to redeem her reputation” because she was ashamed of what she’d done. Multiple figures also blamed the popular podcast Call Her Daddy and its host Alex Cooper for potentially influencing Doe to allow herself “to be treated like a sex doll” and supposedly telling young women to “spread their legs for any man that wants them and there will be no consequences.”
Sirius XM host Megyn Kelly said that it was more “comfortable” for Doe to allege rape than to admit that she had “multiple threesomes with different men on one night.” Kelly also lobbed further personal attacks at Doe, saying she's “not the most attractive gal” and probably “kept saying yes” because she “liked the feeling of being sexy and desired and wanted.” Kelly mocked singer Olivia Rodrigo for posting in support of Doe, saying, “Olivia, in sum, you don't know what the fuck you're talking about. Shut up and stick to singing."
Extreme misogynist streamer Nick Fuentes told his audience that “if a woman in your life was doing something like this, I would absolutely beat the fucking shit out of her.” He called Doe the “Cornell slut” and said she needs to be “put in jail.”
He and others also connected the case to the supposed “hypocrisy” of feminism, with Fuentes saying, “If she's a victim of sex because she's on drugs and alcohol, then maybe it means that her testimony counts for a little bit less, and maybe she can't vote.” Others echoed his rejection of feminism, positing that Doe's accusation shows women believe they “can't be held accountable for their decisions.”
Many others expressed outrage at the way the accused men are being treated in the media, comparing the reactions to a “modern-day lynch mob.” YouTuber Brett Cooper lamented that she could not be “instantly sympathetic” to women who share their stories of sexual assault because “after watching the vitriol with which modern women treat men, it is nearly impossible to be a rational, common sensical person and not be a skeptic.”
-
Right-wing media figures spewed vitriol at Jane Doe, saying she “allowed herself to be treated like a sex doll,” is “not the most attractive gal,” and that she should “be put in jail”
-
- While discussing the case, Megyn Kelly said, “Note to young women on college campuses and beyond: Don't consume 10 drinks in an evening and expect good things to happen to you. They won't.” She continued, “You can take it to the bank. Ten drinks in three hours? What do you think is going to happen? You think your judgment's going to be intact?” Kelly added, “So it was reckless for this woman to do this, and she's dealing with the consequences of that right now.” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 9/30/26]
- In a later episode, Kelly attacked Doe's appearance: “I'm just going to be honest, she's not the most attractive gal. She's extremely beefy in her arms and her legs.” She continued, “And why can't we account for that possibility? That the girl who was never the most sought after suddenly had four guys who wanted to have sex with her. And she counted this, yeah, in her inebriated state, as a win and liked the feeling of being sexy and desired and wanted. It happens. Sorry, it does. And that's why she kept saying yes.” Kelly later attacked women who came out in support of Doe online: “Of course, because the left in particular is what it is, we are seeing the most unattractive women in America post videos claiming, ‘I am Jane Doe.’ Trust me, you have nothing to worry about.” She added, “Everyone's obese and homely and they want us to know, ‘I am Jane Doe.’” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 10/2/26, 10/5/26]
- Nick Fuentes said the “Cornell slut” needs to “be put in jail.” He said, “If anything, she should get a billion-dollar judgment against her like Alex Jones. She should be imprisoned for falsely accusing the men.” [Rumble, America First with Nick Fuentes, 10/1/26]
- Emily Saves America host Emily Wilson said, “The fact that the tipping point for her [Doe] was not getting invited to the party just proves not only is she a shitty person and gross, she's also extremely resentful and spiteful.” Wilson said, “So it's everyone's fault but hers. … It's the boys' fault for taking advantage of her because when you literally offer — and I know the text was bad when it said free pussy, but she did. She offered her pussy for free to multiple different men.” [Instagram, 10/1/26]
- Several right-wing figures blamed popular podcast Call Her Daddy, hosted by Alex Cooper, for normalizing the kind of behavior they claim Doe engaged in. Megyn Kelly said the podcast is telling young women to “spread their legs for any man that wants them and there will be no consequences,” yelling, “F these people. F that woman [Cooper] and her messaging and the young women who got manipulated by her into thinking this is what female empowerment looks like.” Fox contributor Kaylee McGhee White said on Instagram that the podcast probably had “some sort of influence on Jane Doe because she willingly walked into a situation and allowed herself to be treated like a sex doll, and afterward realized how degrading it was.” Finally, Emily Wilson said Doe was feeling “shame and guilt” like she “should have felt, but she's been listening to too much Call Her Daddy, how gang bangs are empowering and sucking dick the best is the best.” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 10/2/26; Instagram, 10/2/26, 10/1/26]
- PBD Podcast panelist Vincent Oshana said, “So if you're violently gang raped over and over and over during the course of a night, you're going to wait three weeks before you're calling the campus police? I'm sorry, guys. I don't believe it.” He added, “I genuinely feel bad for her. The whole situation is horrible, but you put yourself in that dangerous situation, OK? That doesn't give anybody the right to sexually assault you, but you can't also, like, remove personal responsibility from your actions and then blame everybody afterwards.” [Valuetainment, PBD Podcast, 10/2/26]
- Podcaster Tim Pool said that by making the rape accusations, Doe had “betrayed her friends.” Reacting to details in a New York Times article that portrayed Doe as disappointed at being disinvited from a subsequent party, Pool said in a video titled “SHE WAS LYING??!” that Doe “wanted to come back for another gang bang.” [YouTube, Timcast, 10/2/26, 10/2/26; The New York Times, 10/1/26]
- The Federalist CEO Sean Davis suggested that Doe and others who have made accusations of sexual assault are “retconning” their experiences because “being a slut and being a ho is shameful behavior.” Davis said, “We have got to stop doing this thing where people make terrible, deliberate, fully clear decisions about what to do sexually, feel bad about it — rightfully because being a slut and being a ho is shameful behavior and no one should be doing it — and then retconning the whole thing days later when they realize, oh, that thing that I thought was going to make me cool has actually made me a pariah, and then deciding, oh, it must have been rape. This sort of nonsense has to be eradicated from society because what this is actually doing is creating a complete lack of accountability for anyone, and it just has to stop.” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 10/2/26]
- Kelly said that it was more “comfortable” for Doe to allege rape than to admit that she had “multiple threesomes with different men on one night.” Kelly continued, “It's just a much, much better place to be. I'm not a slut, I'm not easy, I'm not a humiliated, desperate, give it up to anybody, you know, person doing drugs off of a man's penis. That's not me. I was coerced. I'm a victim. There are bad people involved in this, but I'm not one of them.” In a later episode, Kelly said, “You know why there was never a question about whether I was gang raped or had three threesomes in a night? Because I never did that. I never ever put myself in a situation where that would even be a remote possibility of a question someone would ask. It's miraculous how that works.” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 9/30/26, 10/5/26]
-
Figures on the right blamed “modern hookup culture” for sexual assaults and claimed we need to “roll back” or have a “reevaluation of” feminism, with some attempting to turn the matter into a debate about whether women have agency
-
- Nick Fuentes said the case demonstrates why we need to “roll back feminism.” He said, “We've got to start holding women accountable for their own actions. It is past due. … They say, I don't defend rapists, I don't defend this. Well, you know what? I don't defend sluts.” [Rumble, America First with Nick Fuentes, 9/30/26]
- Fuentes: “Hypothetically, if a woman in your life was doing something like this, I would absolutely beat the fucking shit out of her.” Referencing “looksmaxxing” influencer Clavicular, who was recently accused of the sexual assault of a minor, and Lindsay Clancy, who recently stood trial for allegedly killing her three children, Fuentes said, “It's between this and Clavicular and Lindsay Clancy. You know what the pattern is? It's that women are never accountable, ever, for their own actions. Women, if they kill their children, if they go to a gang bang, if they get drunk and sleep with a guy, they're never accountable for their own actions. … A girl knows exactly what she's doing as they always have since the fall in the Garden of Eden.” [Rumble, America First with Nick Fuentes, 9/30/26; NPR, 9/22/26; Media Matters, 9/16/26]
- Fuentes said if women are equal, “she raped the men too,” but that if she did not assault the men, then “you got to take it further and say, OK, if she's a victim of sex because she's on drugs and alcohol, then maybe it means that her testimony counts for a little bit less, and maybe she can't vote.” He continued, “And maybe why is she leaving the house and going to this party by herself then? If we want to say that women are vulnerable and women can’t take accountability and women don’t have full agency, then that also means they can’t have full control either. … It means that we’re going to have to treat women a lot differently with regard to the law, then, if you want the double standard, and I think that makes a lot more sense. And that means you got to take their power away. Feminism must be eradicated.” [Rumble, America First with Nick Fuentes, 10/1/26]
- Manosphere streamer Amrou Fudl, who goes by Myron Gaines, read a social media post he made on his stream in which he wrote, “The Cornell 7 case has proven Me Too and feminism need a real reevaluation.” He continued, “Feminism sold equality and delivered demands with zero accountability on women," adding, “Being a 304 and then feeling bad about it is not rape. If you want the right to retroactively withdraw consent, you should never have had the right to consent in the first place. You're either an adult with autonomy, which means responsibility, or you're a child under your parents, with none.” [Kick, MyronGainesX, 10/1/26; Southern Poverty Law Center, 7/29/25]
- Emily Wilson posted that women are admitting “they can't be held accountable for their decisions.” She wrote, “You cannot demand complete autonomy while simultaneously arguing that you're incapable of being accountable for what you do with it.” [Instagram, 9/30/26]
- Wilson said women posting online about their experiences with sexual assault seem “crazy and damaged, and by putting that on the internet for everyone to see, probably no one's going to want to touch you or date you.” She continued, “And also, you're providing zero evidence, and also, let's just start keeping shit to ourselves.” Wilson also said, “By the way, I'm supposed to take these bitches seriously when they act like grape and assault and men are the number one threat to their existence and safety while they vote to import millions of Third World men that see them as less than human, that come here and quite literally don't know you can't do that to women? Really?” [Instagram, 9/30/26, 9/30/26]
- The Daily Wire's Matt Walsh posted that you can “understand the case” when you “understand that feminists fundamentally reject the idea that women can ever be truly responsible for any wrong doing of any kind.” He complained that when there’s a “disgusting drug and alcohol fueled orgy where everyone involved is inebriated, the woman is somehow automatically the victim and the men are somehow automatically responsible.” [Instagram, 9/30/26]
- While discussing the case, Newsmax host Rob Schmitt said, “Modern feminism is loaded with hypocrisy.” He said, “If you agree to ingest drugs and alcohol, then while intoxicated on both you agree to have essentially an orgy, you are not a rape victim and no amount of fury from the outrage machine should ever change that.” [Newsmax, Rob Schmitt Tonight, 9/30/26]
- Antifeminist YouTuber Pearl Davis said Doe “used her beauty and her sexuality to lure innocent young men into a gang bang.” She continued, “They say women need to be protected in this society. No. Men need to be protected because women are the ones ruining their lives for no reason. You know, feminists used to fight to be whores. Now they're fighting for women not to have the right to consent to whoredom.” [Newsmax, Rob Schmitt Tonight, 10/1/26; Yahoo Life, 7/10/23]
- Turning Point USA's Alex Clark posted to Instagram: “WE NEED MORE SLUT SHAMING. NOT LESS.” [Instagram, 10/1/26]
- Tim Pool said the debate is now “largely around whether or not women have agency.” He later expanded on this point, saying, “The issue here is that if a man and a woman are under the influence voluntarily — together as friends — if under the influence, they get together, the man raped her. And we've seen this before. This is exactly what we saw in the Me Too era. But of course, in the era of Lindsay Clancy and Christa Pike, there are women online that just don't care. Women can't do anything wrong.” [YouTube, Timcast, 10/2/26]
- The Daily Wire's Michael Knowles said he thinks Doe is a “victim, not even exactly of the boys, but of feminism, of our modern hookup culture." He continued, saying she was a victim of “the lax social policies of universities, of the totally upended standards and mores when it comes to sex. I think she is kind of a victim.” He later added, “But I don't see any evidence whatsoever that these guys committed a crime according to the law.” [The Daily Wire, The Michael Knowles Show, 9/30/26]
-
Others complained the defendants are facing a “Salem witch trial” or a “modern-day lynch mob”
-
- Megyn Kelly said that coverage of the case was “turning into, I mean, full Salem witch trial." She continued, “These guys are being lynched in the media before we've heard anything.” [SiriusXM, The Megyn Kelly Show, 10/1/26]
- Conspiracy theorist Alex Jones called the investigation the “Salem Witch Hunt 2.0” and referred to Jane Doe as “the super slut.” Jones said, “It's designed to make guys so paranoid. They get into porn. They just get away from women. They become gay, whatever it is, because women are so dangerous.” Jones said his son told him he hasn't dated recently because “the majority of them, when you don't date them again, they say you raped them.” [Alex Jones Live, 10/4/26]
- Podcast host Alex Clark posted a poll on her Instagram story that asked, “And when I say that the Cornell 7 are looking not guilty of rape are we all ready for that conversation or will we get a Lindsey Clancy-type-banshee-screaming response?” [Instagram, 9/30/26]
- Fox News host Will Cain called the online response to the case a “modern-day lynch mob” and said that any person who “broadcast these lies for cheap virtue, or worse, audience and money” should be charged at minimum with “civil defamation charges.” He also alleged that Doe made “allegations of a seven-hour, seven-person gang rape as a way to redeem her reputation.” [Fox News, The Will Cain Show, 10/1/26]
- While discussing other women who have shared their sexual assault stories in reaction to the Cornell case, YouTuber Brett Cooper said, “I wish that when a woman was sitting down in front of me and was telling me all of these things, I wish that I could be instantly sympathetic.” She continued, “I want to be. I wish that my first instinct was not to be hypercritical. But after watching the vitriol with which modern women treat men, it is nearly impossible to be a rational, common sensical person and not be a skeptic especially when, in my opinion, allegedly, regret and shame have the potential to overshadow reality.” [YouTube, The Brett Cooper Show 10/2/26]