The Islamophobic rhetoric spewed by right-wing media in response to the deadly attack on the French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo in Paris is just the most recent in a long history of conservative anti-Islam vitriol.
Right-wing media rushed to exploit the deadly attack on the French satirical newspaper Charlie Hebdo in Paris. But this is just the latest in right-wing media's long history of politicizing tragedy to push political objectives.
Fox host Eric Bolling called on the New York Police Department to engage in more racial profiling and stop-and-frisk after the terrorist attack on the offices of a satirical French magazine, but his characterization of the legality and constitutionality of race-based policing misrepresents these practices.
On January 7, masked gunmen attacked the headquarters of Charlie Hebdo, a French weekly that had previously run caricatures of the Prophet Muhammad. Right-wing media were quick to politicize the attack and describe it as an argument for the practice of race-based police tactics in America, even those prohibited by federal law or the U.S. Constitution. On the January 7 edition of Fox & Friends, co-host Elisabeth Hasselbeck suggested that NYPD officers should be able to target certain communities without fear of being painted with "a racist brush." Hasselbeck also suggested that New York Mayor Bill de Blasio had demoralized the NYPD and threatened security by calling on the police to stop improper racial profiling.
As right-wing media have done repeatedly in the past, Hasselbeck failed to recognize that police practices must pass a threshold of constitutionality regardless of their alleged efficacy at imposing "order."
This narrative continued on the January 7 broadcast of Outnumbered, where Fox host Eric Bolling joined the panel to claim that people in New York should feel "anger" toward de Blasio for his efforts to eliminate unconstitutional stop-and-frisk policies and curb racial profiling. Bolling argued that police had used racial profiling "so effectively for so long" to target people who are "the type of person who's done it in the past." Bolling went on to wonder, "How did profil[ing] become a) unethical, b) illegal? It's throughout history been the most effective law enforcement tool." Outnumbered co-host Andrea Tantaros agreed with Bolling that "leftist mayors like de Blasio" and the Obama administration had "taken those tools away at a time when we need them the most," and claimed that "targeting mosques" was "crucial" towards uncovering terrorist activity:
Luego del ataque terrorista a una revista satírica en Francia, el conductor de Fox,Eric Bolling,hizo un llamado al Departamento Policial de Nueva York (NYPD,por sus siglas en inglés) para que lleve a cabo más prácticas de detención y registro por medio de etiquetamiento racial.Sin embargo, lamanera en la que caracterizó la legalidad y constitucionalidad de este estilo de ejercer la vigilancia policial - basado en raza - no representa correctamente estas prácticas.
El 7 de enero, enmascarados armados atacaron las oficinas centrales de Charlie Hebdo, una revista semanal francesa que había publicado caricaturas del Profeta Muhammad. Los medios conservadores rápidamente politizaron el ataque y lo describieron como un argumento a favor de la práctica de tácticas policiales basadas en raza dentro de los EE.UU., incluso de aquellas que prohíbe la legislación federal o la Constitución de EE.UU. En la edición del 7 de enero del programa Fox & Friends, la co-presentadora Elisabeth Hasselbeck sugirió que los oficiales del NYPD deberían estar autorizados a enfocarse en comunidades particulares sin temor a ser pintados "con un brochazo racista." Hasselbeck también sugirió que el Alcalde de Nueva York Bill de Blasio era culpable de bajarle la moral al NYPD y que había puesto en riesgo la seguridad al exigirle a la policía que pusiera un alto a prácticas indebidas de etiquetamiento racial.
Tal y como ha sido la costumbre de los medios conservadores en el pasado, Hasselback omitió reconocer que las prácticas policiales deben pasar un umbral de constitucionalidad independientemente de su supuesta eficacia para imponer el "orden."
Esta narrativa continuó en la edición del 7 de enero de Outnumbered, en la que el conductor de Fox Eric Bolling se incorporó al panel para alegar los neoyorquinos deben estar furiosos con de Blasio por sus esfuerzos para eliminar la inconstitucional práctica de detención-y-registro y reducir el etiquetamiento racial. Bolling argumentó que la policía ha usado el etiquetamiento racial "de maneras muy efectivas por mucho tiempo" para enfocarse en personas que son "el tipo de sujeto que ya lo ha hecho antes." Bolling continúo para preguntarse en voz alta "¿Cómo es que etiquetar se volvió a) no ético, b) ilegal? Ha sido a lo largo de la historia la herramienta más efectiva para el mantenimiento del orden." La co-presentadora de Outnumbered Andrea Tantaros coincidió con Bolling en que "alcaldes de izquierda como de Blasio" y la administración Obama "nos han quitado esas herramientas en el momento en que más las necesitamos" y argumentó que "tener a las mezquitas como objetivo" era "crucial" para descubrir actividades terroristas:
Conservative media personalities have long ignored the public's overwhelming support for wider access to birth control, instead pushing long debunked myths that birth control is cheap and easy to access, is only about preventing pregnancies, and can cause abortion.
Here are the facts behind right-wing media's three biggest myths about birth control:
Conservative media issued catastrophic predictions and myths about the Affordable Care Act (ACA) in 2014, despite ample evidence that the health care law is working. Media Matters looks back at six claims about Obamacare that didn't pan out for the right-wing media this year.
Fox News is firing shots at House Intelligence Committee Chairman Mike Rogers (R-MI) after he criticized conservative attempts to delegitimize the Committee's report on Benghazi.
In November, the Republican-led House Intelligence Committee released the results of a two-year investigation that "debunk[ed] a series of persistent allegations," pushed by conservative media, about the 2012 attacks on a diplomatic facility in Benghazi. Several Republican lawmakers publicly denounced the report, including Sen. Lindsey Graham (R-SC), who said on CNN that he thought the report "is full of crap." Talking Points Memo reported on December 12 that Rogers "brushed off" criticism from fellow Republicans unsatisfied with his committee's findings:
The Weekly Standard also published a piece quoting a number of members arguing that the Bengahzi report was incomplete. Rogers said those comments were just because the outcome wasn't what those members wanted.
"First of all, they didn't read the report. And unfortunately people wanted this report to be the expansive Benghazi report," Rogers told TPM and other reporters right after the Christian Science Monitor Breakfast. "I told everyone, including some members on my committee that it was not going to be an expansive Benghazi report. My jurisdiction -- the committee's jurisdiction was the lane of the intelligence community. So I think they wanted a report to come out to go after the State Department or the White House. That was not my goal. I put no piece of information in a finding if we couldn't corroborate the information. So one piece of testimony is not corroboration. I had to have other corroboration in order to do it."
Rogers said that none of the criticism has been on the findings.
Fox News host Andrea Tantaros responded by suggesting Rogers manipulated the report's conclusions to protect his wife, who was "doing some consulting on security on the ground at the time" of the Benghazi attacks. From the December 12 edition of Fox News' Outnumbered (emphasis added):
TANTAROS: And there's also questions about Mike Rogers, because he put out that report recently. And some Republicans on the committee are very unhappy with him. They have questions.
So he put out this report where he said, oh, nothing happened here, nothing to see here. No Republicans endorsed it. Wasn't his wife doing some consulting on security on theground at the time? So this isn't just a partisan issue. And it is, it is an issue now because the State Department just this week, and we talked about this a couple days ago, Harris, reported that our embassies are still not secure. So in the wake of the torture memo, have we learned anything?
Tantaros' attacks represent a new, more aggressive angle in Fox's ongoing attempt to discredit the report's findings.
Right-wing media are relying on a litany of myths to defend the use of torture on terrorism suspects, responding to the findings of a Senate investigation on the practice by pretending "torture isn't torture" and improperly crediting brutal interrogation for information that led to the capture of Osama bin Laden.
From the December 9 edition of Fox News' Outnumbered:
Loading the player reg...
From the December 4 edition of Fox News' The O'Reilly Factor:
Loading the player reg...
Conservative media have adopted a "blame feminism" approach to many of the world's problems, including rape and the lack of infrastructure funding. Here are 11 times right-wing media blamed feminism for creating the crisis of the day:
1. Ben Carson blamed the unrest in Ferguson, MO on the "women's lib movement."
2. Conservative blogger Glenn Reynolds accused feminists of derailing infrastructure funding.
3. Rush Limbaugh blamed feminism for the NFL's punishment of football players.
4. On Fox News, Laura Ingraham suggested gender equality and "political correctness" were to blame for a security breach at the White House because the intruder was able to overpower a female security agent.
5. In the wake of the Ray Rice domestic abuse case, the extreme conservative website WND blamed domestic violence on feminism.
6. The Weekly Standard blamed the epidemic of campus sexual assault on feminism being "in control of America's colleges and universities."
7. On June 15, Fox News' Fox & Friends Sunday accused feminists of trying to "end" Father's Day.
8. The hosts of Fox News' Outnumbered agreed that feminism is to blame for boys falling behind in school.
9. During a March 31 Heritage Foundation panel commemorating Women's History Month, conservative columnist Mona Charon cited the alleged "disintegration of family function" as one of feminism's many "failures."
10. In a discussion on Fox News' The Five about a female teacher who had sex with her 15-year old student, co-host Andrea Tantaros claimed "women who do this feel like it's not as stigmatizing as it was before," insisting that "there's something about feminism that lets them know 'I can do anything that a man does, I can even go after that young boy. I deserve it.'"
11. In 2012, Rush Limbaugh claimed that feminism is "ruining women."
Right-wing media's outrage over President Obama's upcoming speech outlining plans to improve enforcement of the immigration system included accusations that Obama is engaging in "home-grown tyranny," calls for his impeachment, and even a Hitler comparison.
From the November 20 edition of Fox News' Outnumbered:
Loading the player reg...
Right-wing media resurrected the myth that increased immigration hurts American workers in response to President Obama's plans for executive action on immigration. In fact, studies consistently find that immigration does not lead to higher unemployment or lower American wages and that it actually helps the economy.
Fox News is sending a mixed message about whether or not President Barack Obama has the legal authority to address the immigration crisis through executive action, even though legal experts agree that such action is perfectly lawful.
After Republicans in the House failed to consider a comprehensive and bipartisan immigration reform bill passed by the Senate, President Obama announced that he would take steps to address the issue through lawful executive actions. One possibility is the expansion of the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program, which temporarily halts deportation proceedings for young law-abiding undocumented immigrants -- an exercise of standard prosecutorial discretion typical of law enforcement agencies. After the Democrats lost control of the Senate on November 5, the president repeated his promise to move on immigration reform in the absence of congressional action, explaining at a press conference that "we're gonna take whatever lawful actions that I can take that I believe will improve the functioning of our immigration system."
Some Fox News hosts were skeptical about whether the president has the authority to take unilateral executive action, however. On the November 7 edition of Outnumbered, co-host Andrea Tantaros complained that Obama "doesn't care about the constitution" and that he would "get away with" executive action on immigration because "some pointy-nosed Harvard lawyers [will argue] whether or not this is constitutional."
Tantaros' complaints echoed her Fox colleague Sean Hannity, who on the November 6 edition of his show criticized the president's pledge to take executive action on immigration. In an interview with Sen. Mike Lee (R-UT), Hannity argued that the president "may not have the authority do this" and that "immigration law does not allow for the amnesty that the president wants to grant." Lee agreed with Hannity's assessment, and suggested that the proposed order would "lead us from behind into a constitutional crisis":